Category: #MeToo

The Kiss that Overshadowed Spanish Women’s Soccer History

Women’s soccer is a passion of mine and while USA is my team, even I had to admit that at this year’s FIFA Women’s World Cup Spain was a dominant force. Their team was among the best, if not the best, that I had watched in my time as a fan. I spent the cup in awe of their ability. This came at a time in which women’s sports are beginning to gain traction, more people than ever watched the NCAA Women’s Basketball Tournament, the University of Nebraska’s women’s volleyball team broke the record for highest attendance at a women’s sporting event, and the World Cup itself was gaining viewership. This team was poised to make history and make history they did. In front of the eyes of the world they brought home Spain’s first ever Women’s World Cup Final victory. Unfortunately, the attention on their victory did not last.

During their celebrations, Vice President of the Royal Spanish Football Federation, Luis Rubiales kissed player Jenni Hermoso without her consent. Within the week Spanish soccer shut down. No longer were discussions of the women’s team about their victory, but instead about this kiss and the perpetrator who refuses to step down.

The public outcry has been somewhat unique compared to many incidents in women’s sports. In past instances the supporters of the women that were impacted by these events are majority women as well, especially within the realm of support from other athletes, but this time was different. Players from men’s and women’s teams across Spain made statements in open opposition to Rubiales continuing to hold his office. Athletes from both sections of Spanish soccer have pledged to refuse to play for Spain so long as Rubiales remains in office.

Are there instances that have played out in a similar manner in other settings? I’m curious if there has been similar support for a woman in this sort of situation outside of sports.

Men Fearful After #MeToo Movement

This article by the HuffPost discusses backlash to the #MeToo movement. We discussed in class and read about different negative opinions about and criticisms of the #MeToo movement. I was interested to see how these negative opinions and criticisms could negatively affect the movement’s progress in helping prevent sexual harassment in the workplace. The article discusses how a significantly larger number of men feel uncomfortable mentoring or socializing with women since the movement began. Men are now more aware of their actions and do not want to risk making women feel uncomfortable.

Although false accusations are rare, men seem to believe that a lot of the accusations that have come about because of the #MeToo movement are fabricated and untruthful. Men believe that their interactions with women will look inappropriate to others and get them into some sort of trouble because of accusations of sexual harassment. This affects relationships in the workplace. With more men holding higher positions at work and women being excluded from meetings and social outings, women are unable to advance in their careers. It is now harder for women to do their jobs and get ahead. Has this consequence of the movement caused more harm than good? 

The article brings up how if men want to help be a solution to the issue of sexual harassment and rape then they should not stop interacting with women altogether. With men not wanting to interact with women, women cannot advance in their careers which ultimately doesn’t help solve the issue of sexual harassment in the workplace. Having women in higher positions, where men are, can help solve the issue of sexual harassment.

While reading a few questions came to mind. Why would men be scared to interact women if they aren’t sexual predators themselves? Is this part of a larger sociological issue? If all they have to do is not be predatory, why would that be difficult to do? What does this say about how men are socialized? It may have something to do with rape culture and how normalized predatory behavior is in media.

 

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/me-too-backlash-getting-worse_n_5cddd96de4b00e035b8ce786

 

Abusive Men in Hip-Hop

In class, we discussed cancel culture today and how many music artists who have allegations against them are able to continue their careers and not be held accountable. This article discusses men in hip-hop specifically and highlights a very important issue in the music industry and society in general. Why are abusive men in hip-hop not held accountable for violence against women? When will we start holding abusive men in hip-hop accountable?

While this article was written a few years ago (2018), it still addresses a key issue going on today regarding sexual harassment and violence against women. Many artists today, many of which listed in this article, still have thriving careers despite the many allegations against them. Music artists such as Chris Brown, Eminem, and XXXTentacion, have remained on billboard charts despite their many allegations of violence against women. XXXTentacion was actually able to rise to fame despite all the allegations against him. Even after his death, people continue to mourn his death and continue to defend him.

XXXTentacion

 

Fans of these artists seem to brush their allegations under the rug and continue to support them, but what does this say about fans of these people. What does this say about the limitations of the #MeToo movement in reaching fans of hip-hop?

The article also discusses how other music artists, in this case Nicki Minaj, have continued to work with men who have allegations against them, specifically 6ix9ine who pleaded guilty to sexual assault of a minor. Nicki Minaj has also remained silent about the abusive behaviors of her own brother. How does this silence further the issue of accountability in the music industry?

“Separate the art from the artist” is a statement I hear often when people justify listening to problematic artists. They claim to just listen to their music because they enjoy the music, not because they like or support the actions of the person. But is this a valid argument? Can we really separate the art from the artist? By listening and consuming their art, are we not indirectly supporting the person and their actions. Are we not helping advance their career? And is that not justifying their abusive behavior? Is it really worth it to brush violence against women under the rug just because they make good music? What does this say about us as consumers and fans?

 

https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/sylviaobell/times-up-metoo-abusive-men-hip-hop

#MeToo and “Sexual Harassment and Hollywood’s Earliest Cartoons”

Sexual Harassment and Hollywood’s Earliest Cartoons

 

In a 2017 post titled “Sexual Harassment and Hollywood’s Earliest Cartoons” the author, Gabrielle Bellot, explained that recent claims of sexual harassment from Harvey Weinstein that started the #MeToo movement are what inspired her to investigate sexual harassment in Hollywood. Upon hearing about these claims she was reminded of sexual harassment depicted in old cartoons. Depictions of harassment towards women can be found in Hollywood through cartoons as well. A few examples are: Mickey Mouse, Little Red Riding Hood, and most importantly, Max Fleischer’s Betty Boop cartoons.

 

Whether the Betty Boop cartoon was meant as a children’s cartoon or an adult cartoon is up for debate. There are many specific episodes where Betty Boop is so obviously being harassed and even almost raped. The cartoon mirrored instances of the real world, bad ones. Episodes of Betty Boop depict stalking, sexual harassment in the workplace, and even an instance where rape is implied in the show. While most of these actions might go over the heads of children, adults can clearly see the problem. 

 

These types of cartoons were released around the time that the entertainment industry in Hollywood was being exposed. In the 1920’s, many scandals involving sexual assault, drugs, and even murder were being exposed to the public and being brushed under the rug in the courtroom. Hollywood releasing such controversial cartoons could either be seen as a cry for help or as a way to simply say “this is how stuff is around here”. Normalizing sexual harassment towards women could easily be done through cartoons like this. Which could explain why this type of harassment is still around today. Actions like the ones depicted in the cartoon such as workplace sexual harassment had the power to influence little boys. According to learning theory, used in psychology, actions like these could be learned. For example, a boy that witnesses a man getting what he wants with a woman in a cartoon at a young age may be more subconsciously willing to do the same when he gets in the same position of power when he is older. A little boy who watched a cartoon of many people in a work force working together and including both men and women might subconsciously be more open to working with both genders.  

 

Another theory based on why the cartoons were created could be found if you look a little deeper. In the episode “Betty Boop’s Big Boss”, Betty responds to a help wanted sign, clearly describing a position for a girl. Betty is asked what she can do and she responds by singing the boss a song. The boss is then shown daydreaming about what it would be like to be with Betty. While she is still singing, he sends all of the other girls away. Betty Bopp is then shown “provoking” the boss. While it may look like Betty Boop is the one provoking the boss, some people may see it differently. From his perspective, he may presume Betty’s actions or words are sexual advances. In reality, Betty’s naturally high pitched voice and friendly mannerisms may have been wrongly interpreted as flirtatious. After the boss hires Betty, she begins to work but then suddenly, Betty hits the boss with a piece of the typewriter and he snaps out of it. He asks Betty for a kiss and she rejects him. After being rejected the boss starts to walk towards her, when Betty tries to run away, the door is locked. Betty calls the police, but even they can not get to him because he is up high in his building. This part may suggest that a woman being harassed may not get justice if the abuser has a lot of power or is a member of the upper class. After the police fail to get the boss, Betty tries shooting him with a pencil sharpener. The boss only yells out once but still has a smile on his face. This could also be interpreted as Betty not having enough power to stop him. Finally, the only way to take down the boss is by shooting at the base of the building. The building falls with the boss still in it but Betty Boop goes down as well. This shows that Betty was not able to ask for help without going down along with her abuser. This has been the case for many women that have spoken up about their harassment in the workplace, even in Hollywood.

 

Bellot explains that “Harassment was braided to the industry from its beginnings; there were many Weinsteins before Weinstein”. Although this was a recurring problem, there were many women who were afraid to speak up about their abuse. The issue being spread through cartoons may have been a tool to help people cope. The cartoons may have helped them watch and laugh through the situation. On the other hand, they may have mirrored these Hollywood scandals to raise awareness in a discrete way. Women were not safe if they spoke up. In “The Limits of #MeToo in Hollywood”, Margaret Talley explains that even though laws were made to prevent sexual harassment in the workplace, these laws were not abided. Thanks to activists like Tarana Burke and Alyssa Milano, and movements like the #MeToo movement, women in the United States are finally getting the justice they deserve.

 

Blog Post #1 (9/13/21)

For my first blog post assignment, I wanted to incorporate the #MeToo movement that has been ever so prevalent in our class over the past couple of weeks. The article that I chose was published by The Washington Post and is called “#Metoo raised awareness about sexual misconduct. Has it curbed bad behavior?” The author of this article, Ellen McCarthy, brings up the reported cases of sexual assault against former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo and how his behavior was maintained because of his position of power.

To break down the article, McCarthy begins with the betrayal that is felt because of atrocities that Cuomo performed without consent. Cuomo was known for being a “public advocate for legislation that has made it easier for women in his state to seek redress for sexual harassment and rape,” so it raises the question as to how his words and actions could be so contradictory? Instead of the thought that men had learned how to control their sexual insinuations/conduct towards women from the #MeToo movement, only awareness, and victim understanding were raised which does not curb the behavior.

It is made clear in the article that this type of behavior has not decreased because of the “power dynamic” that primarily men hold over women. This call for change will only occur if mindsets change, but the system is not one that will protect the innocent, instead, it is “set up to protect powerful people,” says, former policy attorney at the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Elaine Herskowitz. But just because these powerful individuals have deluded themselves to believe their actions are appropriate, does not mean that reports have not continued to be filed against them. In 2018, a 13 percent increase in harassment claims were made, which is “attributed to the #MeToo movement.” Filed claims have still continued to rise because of the #MeToo movement, but it is counterintuitive to report with pride that claims have increased because it draws attention to the fact that sexual harassment is still just as frequent as before. With that being said, a professor at the University of Colorado who has done studies on the #MeToo movement’s impact on women found that sexual coercion such as “have sex with me or you’re fired” is less common, and harassment claims are less severe. Blatant harassment is still plentiful and Susan Strauss attributes that to “…some men that have a pathology that drives them to view women in this way. I think some will say, ‘Well, it’s not that big a deal. She needs to pull up her bootstraps and deal with it.’ And some will say, ‘Well, if it’s not so bad that it’s illegal then I’m just going to continue to do it.’ ” With this harmful mindset, the hope for change from the #MeToo movement will be stunted until legislation is passed that allows victims to speak out against their offenders.

As more women are appointed to higher positions in companies, with an accompanied higher wage, less hierarchal sexual harassment will occur. The first step in this battle for a change of behavior today begins with Andrew Cuomo’s resignation which “constitutes a win for the (#MeToo) movement.”

I enjoyed this article because it breaks down the effects of the #MeToo movement, which is what I have only read about in the book we are covering in class. I liked being able to apply what I have already read to modern-day cases of sexual assault/harassment. The #MeToo movement is doing wonderful things by empowering women, now workplace behavior needs to be the focal point that needs to shift for the better for consistent change.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/andrew-cuomo-me-too/2021/08/13/1ae95048-fbed-11eb-8a67-f14cd1d28e47_story.html

The struggles of a “Ko-reer” Woman: Understanding Sexual Harassment Cross-Culturally

By Tiger Hobday

 

The sun scorches on a hot Saturday in downtown Seoul, South Korea. The streets of the Western town located in the city are filled with the hustle-and-bustle of Korean citizens, international tourists, expats and the usual young American soldiers. On the second floor of one of the buildings on the main street is a red-painted restaurant. Inside that restaurant, I am scrambling to take demanding orders from starving customers when a life-changing episode completely alters my perceptions of the world of work and the dynamics inside the restaurant. I was close to my manager at the time, whose smile would later turn into a menacing grin. When I first started the job, he was someone that I could approach. He would praise me for my hard work and would sneak me the best food from the kitchen during lunch breaks. He even once bought me a candle that read, “Marina, the Best Worker in the World.” Little did I know at age of 18 that this man, someone who I trusted in a higher position, would end up sexually harassing me.

A group of American soldiers had entered the restaurant, boisterous and hungry. American soldiers were usually my favorite customers because they tip generously unlike Koreans who do not. Firstly, Koreans do not tip. However, Americans generously tip, especially towards me as I was fluent in English or perhaps because I was a young girl. I was also accustomed to male customers making flirtatious comments, but they never commented on my sexuality or my body. As a result, I never felt unsafe and did not take the comments too seriously. On that day, I took the order from these young men and entered the kitchen. As I was heading back out, my manager took me aside and asked me “Why did you spend so much time talking to those customers? It is not your job to flirt.” The comment took me by surprise, and I was at a loss for words. What was he accusing me of? However, the restaurant was too busy to start an argument with him. I quickly apologized and got back to work.

Throughout the day I started to receive harassing texts from him. “Why do you only go to male customers? Do not act cheap. Go put on more clothes. This is why I don’t like to hire women. I was mesmerized by your pretty face; sad you do not have a pretty personality. Those tips are only earned by your slutty behavior. I am sure that you must be sleeping with these customers on a regular basis, no wonder they keep coming back.” At my shift’s end, I burst into tears in the changing room. I decided I had enough. I walked into the office and confronted my boss about the texts. He looked at me with a cold face and said, “Why are you showing me this?”. I told him it was because it was sexual harassment, and he replied that if it did not affect my work performance it was not a matter of importance.

This event happened in 2015. Only in 2018 did South Korea follow the US in the #MeTooMovement with the primary motive of encouraging victims of sexual harassment to come forward and share their stories. The South Korean Labor and Gender Equality Ministries launched a public campaign program to raise awareness regarding sexual harassment. But would this effort be enough to change things? And why did it take so long to happen?

Experts suggest that public awareness regarding sexual harassment in Asian countries is considerably lower than in Western nations. Patriarchy remains deeply entrenched in the roots of most South Korean communities: it is a society where men hold most of the power and women are mostly excluded from it. This is a traditional family system still practiced through patrilineal lineage where the wife’s role is to hold down the household, subordinate to the father’s position as head of the family. Starting in the late 19th century, women began to become educated in greater numbers due to the introduction of an education system introduced by Western Christian ministries. There were schools that had a specific goal of educating women, the most notorious being Ehwa University which was founded in 1886. By 2000, women in higher education were one third of the student population but in 2016 that rose to 42%. As a result, they are entering the workforce in greater numbers in Korea. However, research reveals that approximately 78% of the sexual harassment victims seldom report their incidents since they lack trust in the system.

The nation’s male-dominated culture places women at an increased risk of becoming potential victims. Women are perceived as inferior regardless of their education and careers; this reflected the experience I had with approaching my boss’ attitude towards the situation. He still did not see my complaint on sexual harassment as one that should be equally addressed in comparison to complaints my coworkers had presented. Such incidents of prejudice and discrimination have discouraged female victims from speaking out about their encounters.

Korea women in professional jobs experience similar issues in the workplace. Unfortunately, South Korean patriarchal culture and traditions help propagate sexual harassment in the workplace. Research shows that men occupying superior office positions promote demeaning and sexually harassing behavior towards women in the lower ranks, reflecting the experience of my male manager and me. Statistical evidence reveals that approximately eight out of ten working women in South Korea are victims of sexual harassment One example is of office parties, where entertainment provided involve escorts or prostitutes and is focused on entertaining male employees or clients. This is seen in big companies that do business with other companies, such as in the entertainment industry, where the aim is to please their clients in order to solidify a business deal that benefits the company financially. They use the sexuality of women through providing female entertainment to show “hospitality” to their clients. This creates a hostile environment for professional women who mostly chose not to participate and are then excluded by their coworkers. The hardships that professional women face seem to be never ending. Don’t you think it is time for it to stop?

On the other hand, when I arrived in the US, I had a completely different work experience. As part of my orientation, I had to complete a workshop on Title IX: a title based on the laws protecting workers against sexual discrimination in the workplace. I was shocked that my job emphasized this training and the protection of women as I never had such an opportunity or education in Korea. Furthermore, by living in the US I have seen the success of how the system apprehends sexual harassers and encourages people to report such incidents. I witnessed how strong the #MeTooMovement was in America, the solidarity between women on social media, the Women’s March in DC and even the Women and Gender Office at my university. These movements and safe places create environment for women to speak about the injustices that they face.

The progress made in the US on providing women legal protections for sexual harassment and the social support for those who speak out gives me hope similar changes can happen world-wide. By all genders uniting on the importance of creating equality through feminism, the unified effort has the potential to create this change. There must be an effort to not just create a culture that frees women and men from patriarchal constraints but also one that detaches men from the assumptions of a patriarchal educational system that encourages them to think less of their female peers. If we accomplish these aims, then the struggles of a Ko-reer woman will have been worth it.

 

Tiger Hobday is an international at East Carolina University and goes by the pronouns She/Hers/Her.  She is originally from London, UK and Seoul, South Korea. She studies sociology with her main focus on feminism and international human rights. In her spare time, she enjoys producing music.

#metoo

We all know that #metoo is a global movement going on right now, and it has to deal with personal experiences of sexual assault. It’s giving woman the platform they need to speak out on men who have abused them and taken their innocence from. But since this is mostly girls speaking out, what about the men? In an article I read, men are now reflecting more on the movement and how it is important to them. The results among men ranging ages from 18-34 was 23%  since the movement started have watched what they do, and tried to change their behavior while the 77% did not change. The news and all the stories have made ALL men think though and make them wonder if they have pushed their partner too far, and made them feel uncomfortable. Men are very oblivious to such things like the women who are in the metoo movement and don’t think they have ever witnessed sexual harassment.

LGBTQ Vulnerability

Link to article: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2018/06/13/sarah-mcbride-gay-survivors-helped-launch-me-too-but-rates-lgbt-abuse-largely-overlooked/692094002/

Sexual assault is a form of violence that disproportionately affects women and minority groups. This can be seen from the rates of sexual assault on LGBTQ people. It’s no shock to me that simply coming out increases one’s risk for sexual assault. The article lists and explains the risk factors LGBTQ people experience including greater risk of alcohol and drug use, homelessness, poverty and lack of employment opportunities. It also explains the role myths about LGBTQ people play in the disproportionate rates of violence.

I found this article interesting because we give the #MeToo movement so much credit for allowing victims to share their stories and find support. However, the stories that get the most attention are those of prominent straight white women and a powerful male assaulter. I think the #MeToo movement is shifting in the right direction, but are we doing enough to allow everyone’s story to be heard?

Why is it that despite the staggering statistics on the rates of sexual assaults on minority groups the stories that get the most attention are those of primarily straight white female celebrities?

Aftermath of abuse: When is it okay to share another’s story?

This particular article posted in the Guest column by News24, is about the aftermath of abuse. The headline asks, “when is it okay to share another’s story?” This is an interesting article to read because we always try to encourage the victims of abuse to speak out, but we never concern ourselves about it being okay to share someone else’s story.

For those victims who are lucky enough to escape their situation or even for those who were not it is important that everyone come together to we lead lives of those who bare a substantive amount of fear. Because as women, we never know whether we are even safe from being taken under the raft of an abuser or a rapist, we must stand together. For those who cannot speak, someone has to speak for them because we cannot continue to hide if we want to see a change.

So, my question to you guys is, when is it okay to speak out? When will enough be enough?

City Press. News24. Aftermath of abuse: When is it okay to share another’s story?. May 27, 2018. <https://www.news24.com/Columnists/GuestColumn/aftermath-of-abuse-when-is-it-okay-to-share-anothers-story-20180527>. June 14, 2018.

Valedictorian asked to not speak of sexual assault

Lulabel Seitz said that she was told by her administrators to not speak about her or other students sexual assault experiences in high school. Almost scared away she decided to still speak on sexual assault during her valedictorian speech. Her microphone was then cut off because the school said that her speech, “wouldn’t help”. When her sexual assault happened the school did nothing and would not comment on cutting off her microphone.

Article: https://www.cnn.com/2018/06/10/us/california-valedictorian-speech-cut-off/index.html

 

What do you think was the school’s motive for not wanting her to talk about sexual assault in her speech?